Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Florida Insurance Claims Lawyers / Blog / Insurance Claims / Florida Insurance Company Sued for Fraudulent Criminal Prosecution

Florida Insurance Company Sued for Fraudulent Criminal Prosecution

_ClaimForm

On September 16th, 2026, Insurance Business Magazine reported that a roofing company had sued a Florida property insurer for allegedly pursuing a fraudulent criminal prosecution. This case may illustrate the lengths to which insurers go to avoid payouts and their contractual obligations. If you believe you are the victim of a fraudulent insurance company in Florida, consider speaking with a lawyer.

Roofer Claims Insurer Put Him Through a “Baseless” Criminal Case

The controversy started when an HOA in Lee County signed an assignment of benefits (AOB) with a roofing contractor. Like many HOAs at that time, the organization needed to repair damage caused by Hurricane Irma in 2021. The contractor estimated the total damage at $414,000, with $233,000 of that set aside for the roof.

The insurance company hired investigators and immediately reported the claim to the Department of Financial Services (DFS), flagging the roofing contractor as a potential scammer. However, the DFS found no evidence of criminal conduct and dismissed the entire affair as a pricing dispute.

Years later, the insurance company prompted another DFS investigation. The roofer’s lawsuit states that this second investigation was triggered by a fraudulent tip provided by a DFS employee with no basis in reality. The employee allegedly listed a homeowner at the condo building as a complainant, but this resident later told the authorities that he had no idea why his name was on the file. From his point of view, the DFS used his name without permission.

The lawsuit also accuses the insurer of concealing independent estimates that supported the roofer’s damage valuations. These estimates allegedly showed that the roofer’s damage estimates were accurate and in no way fraudulent.

In the end, the roofer was arrested for insurance fraud and grand theft. If he had been convicted, he would have faced up to 60 years in prison. In its press release, the DFS publicly denounced the roofer as a criminal.

The investigation then completely fell apart. At the slightest examination of the key facts, it became obvious that everything had been fabricated. According to the lawsuit, key witnesses recanted earlier testimony or provided inconsistent information. Evidence also mysteriously disappeared, including the hard copy of the original 2021 investigation file. One week before the trial, the State of Florida dropped all charges due to insufficient evidence.

The reputation of the roofer was utterly destroyed by the debacle. Even if this lawsuit is successful, he may never be able to rebuild his business. The DFS itself may also face legal action as a result of this failed criminal prosecution. If the lawsuit’s allegations are accurate, it shows how far insurance companies are willing to go to avoid helping ordinary people repair their roofs.

Contact Our Fort Lauderdale Property Insurance Lawyers Today

At Fuxa & Tyler, our legal team is made up of a diverse combination of attorneys who are well-positioned to protect the legal rights and financial interests of policyholders. If your property insurance claim was denied, we can help. For a free consultation, please call us today at (954) 990-5251. With an office in Sunrise, we represent policyholders in Broward County and throughout the state of Florida.

Source: 

https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/news/risk-compliance-legal/tower-hill-faces-malicious-prosecution-suit-after-fraud-case-collapses-590016.aspx