Fort Lauderdale Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer
When an insurance company refuses to honor a valid claim, delays payment without a reasonable basis, or low-balls a loss it knows is covered, that conduct may cross the line from a coverage dispute into bad faith. Fuxa & Tyler is a Florida insurance claims law firm that represents policyholders exclusively, helping individuals, families, and businesses hold insurers accountable when carriers treat their own customers unfairly.
Bad faith insurance law gives policyholders a separate avenue of recovery beyond the underlying claim itself. In plain terms, it means an insurer has an obligation to handle claims honestly and promptly, and when it fails that obligation, the policyholder may be entitled to damages beyond the original policy limits. That is a powerful remedy, but deadlines are strict, and waiting too long can cost you the ability to pursue it. Acting quickly, documenting everything, and speaking with an attorney early are the most important things you can do after a carrier has mishandled your claim.
What Bad Faith Actually Looks Like in a Property Insurance Claim
Bad faith is a legal standard, not just a feeling that your insurer treated you poorly. It describes a pattern of conduct where the carrier puts its own financial interests ahead of the policyholder’s rights under the policy. Understanding what that looks like in practice helps you recognize whether your situation may qualify.
Common patterns include a carrier that acknowledges coverage but then sits on the claim for months without explanation, makes an offer it knows is far below the documented loss, misrepresents what the policy covers, fails to investigate thoroughly or assigns an adjuster who ignores key damage, or denies a claim without citing any real basis in the policy language. Florida policyholders are also protected when a carrier refuses to defend or indemnify under a liability policy in circumstances where a reasonable insurer would have done so.
The distinction between a carrier making a low offer and a carrier acting in bad faith is not always obvious from the outside. A carrier can dispute value in good faith. What it cannot do is manufacture a low number, ignore expert opinions it has in hand, or use procedural tactics to wear a policyholder down into accepting less than the claim is worth. The conduct has to be evaluated in full context, which is one reason these cases benefit from attorneys who have seen how carriers behave from the inside.
Why Fuxa & Tyler Handles Bad Faith Cases Differently
Fuxa & Tyler’s depth in bad faith litigation comes from attorneys who built careers on both sides of the insurance relationship before choosing the policyholder’s side. Attorney Gilberto Barreto spent more than a decade representing insurance carriers in coverage and bad faith litigation before switching sides to represent policyholders. He is AV rated by Martindale-Hubbell and has tried jury and non-jury civil cases in state and federal court. That background means he understands how carriers build their defenses and where those defenses have weaknesses.
Attorney Andrew Fuxa brings a different kind of institutional knowledge. He began his career nearly 30 years ago as a property restoration contractor, later ran a public adjusting company, and personally handled more than 400 property damage appraisals before practicing law. He holds a degree in building construction from the University of Florida. When a carrier disputes what damage costs, he can read those arguments with a contractor’s eye as well as a lawyer’s.
The firm’s results reflect that combination. In a bad faith insurance matter, the firm took a case where the pre-trial offer was $125,000 and resolved it for $1,550,000. In a first-party coverage dispute, a pre-trial offer of $525,000 became a settlement of $1,600,000.
What to Do After a Carrier Mishandles Your Claim
The steps you take in the weeks after a carrier acts improperly shape the case you are able to bring later. The first priority is documentation. Save every piece of correspondence with the insurer: denial letters, emails, adjuster reports, and any written explanations the carrier provides. If conversations happen by phone, follow up in writing summarizing what was said and ask the carrier to correct the record if it disagrees.
Keep all repair estimates, contractor invoices, photographs of damage, and any independent appraisals or inspection reports you have obtained. If you have already repaired emergency damage, retain receipts and before-and-after photos. The carrier’s own adjuster reports, which you are entitled to request, can also become important evidence.
One common mistake is accepting a partial payment without understanding what rights you may be releasing. Another is letting too much time pass before consulting an attorney. Deadlines in bad faith matters are strict, and some of them run from the date of the carrier’s conduct rather than the date of the original loss. Waiting to see whether the carrier comes around on its own often narrows the options available to you. Speaking with an attorney as soon as you recognize a problem is the most reliable way to preserve your full range of remedies.
What the Firm Does at Each Stage of a Bad Faith Case
Fuxa & Tyler works with clients from the first call through resolution, and clients work directly with their attorneys.
- Free initial consultation: An attorney reviews the claim history, the carrier’s conduct, and the policy to assess whether bad faith is viable and explain the options clearly.
- Investigation and loss quantification: The firm draws on its network of public adjusters, contractors, and other professionals to build an accurate picture of the loss the carrier should have paid.
- Demand and pre-suit process: Where required, the firm prepares and delivers formal demand correspondence to the carrier, documenting the basis for the bad faith claim and the damages sought.
- Appraisal or mediation: If the policy or circumstances call for it, the firm represents the client through appraisal proceedings or mediation, preparing thoroughly for each.
- Litigation: When the carrier refuses to resolve the matter fairly, the firm files suit and takes the case as far as necessary, including federal court and appeals where appropriate.
- Client communication throughout: Attorneys meet with clients regularly, explain each stage in plain terms, and keep clients informed whether the matter is at a demand, mediation, or trial.
Frequently Asked Questions About Bad Faith Insurance Claims in Fort Lauderdale
What is a bad faith insurance claim?
A bad faith insurance claim is a legal action against an insurer that failed to handle a policyholder’s claim honestly, promptly, or fairly. The insurer has a duty to its own insured, and when it places its financial interests above that duty, the policyholder may have grounds to seek damages beyond what the policy itself would cover. It is a separate claim from the underlying coverage dispute.
Can I bring a bad faith claim if my insurer simply denied coverage?
A denial alone does not automatically create a bad faith claim. The key question is whether the insurer had a reasonable basis for the denial and whether it investigated properly before issuing it. If the carrier denied a claim it had grounds to know was valid, ignored documentation, or misrepresented policy terms, that conduct may support a bad faith case alongside a coverage claim.
How is a bad faith claim different from a regular insurance dispute?
A regular insurance dispute asks whether the carrier owes the amount claimed under the policy. A bad faith claim asks whether the carrier’s conduct in handling the claim was itself wrongful. The damages available in a bad faith case can reach beyond the policy limits, which is what makes this type of claim meaningfully different for policyholders who have been seriously harmed by carrier misconduct.
How does Fuxa & Tyler charge for these cases?
You pay no attorney’s fee unless we recover for you; case costs are explained in writing before you sign, and your first consultation is free.
What if the insurance company made me a low settlement offer rather than denying the claim outright?
A low offer can be evidence of bad faith if the carrier knew the offer was unreasonable relative to the documented loss. Carriers sometimes use low-ball offers combined with delay tactics to pressure policyholders into settling for far less than their claims are worth. An attorney can evaluate whether the gap between what was offered and what is owed reflects bad faith conduct or a legitimate valuation dispute.
How long do I have to pursue a bad faith claim in Florida?
Deadlines in bad faith matters are strict, and some run from the date of the specific conduct rather than the date of the loss itself. Missing a deadline can eliminate your ability to bring the claim entirely. The only reliable way to understand which deadlines apply to your situation is to speak with an attorney as soon as you recognize a problem with how your claim has been handled.
What records should I keep if I think my insurer acted in bad faith?
Keep every piece of written communication with the carrier, including denial letters, coverage explanations, emails, and adjuster correspondence. Preserve photographs of damage, all repair estimates and invoices, independent inspection or appraisal reports, and notes from phone conversations. The more complete the record, the stronger the foundation for evaluating and pursuing a bad faith claim.
Can I still bring a bad faith claim if I already accepted a partial payment from the insurer?
It depends on the circumstances and what, if anything, you signed when accepting the payment. Some partial payments come with releases that can limit your options, while others do not. Before accepting any payment from a carrier whose conduct you question, speak with an attorney about what rights you may be waiving.
Does it help to have an attorney who used to work for insurance companies?
It often does, particularly in bad faith cases. Attorneys who spent years on the carrier side understand how insurers document claim decisions, what internal standards they are supposed to follow, and where their arguments are weakest. Fuxa & Tyler includes attorneys with that background, which informs how the firm evaluates carrier conduct and builds its cases.
Does Fuxa & Tyler serve Spanish-speaking clients in Fort Lauderdale?
Yes. Several attorneys and staff members at Fuxa & Tyler speak Spanish, and the firm serves clients in the Fort Lauderdale area and throughout South Florida regardless of their preferred language. Clients work directly with their attorneys and can expect the same level of communication and attention regardless of language.
Serving Fort Lauderdale and Broward County
Fort Lauderdale sits in Broward County, a region of densely developed residential neighborhoods, commercial corridors, and waterfront properties that face significant exposure to hurricane, wind, and water damage. Fuxa & Tyler serves policyholders throughout Fort Lauderdale and the surrounding Broward County communities, including Sunrise and the broader South Florida area. Property owners here deal with insurers regularly, and when those insurers fail to treat valid claims fairly, the firm provides the same level of representation it brings to insurance disputes anywhere in Florida, with attorneys who know these markets and the kinds of losses that arise in them.
Talk to a Fort Lauderdale Bad Faith Insurance Attorney
Fuxa & Tyler represents policyholders in bad faith insurance matters throughout Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, and across Florida. If your insurer has mishandled your claim, delayed without reason, or made an offer that falls far short of a documented loss, contact Fuxa & Tyler to schedule your consultation and find out what your options are.
